Mouthrinse vs. Tongue scraping! Which one is better?

Introduction

Maintaining optimal oral hygiene is crucial for overall health, and battling bad breath is a common concern for many. Traditionally, mouth rinse or mouthwash has been a go-to solution for freshening breath. However, recent research suggests that using mouthwash can have unintended consequences by indiscriminately killing both good and bad bacteria in the mouth. In this blog, we'll explore why tongue scraping is emerging as a superior choice for oral health, as it effectively removes bad bacteria while preserving the beneficial ones.

The Problem with Mouth Rinse

Mouth rinse, or mouthwash, has long been a staple in oral care routines. It's promoted for its ability to provide instant freshness and kill bacteria. However, it's important to understand that not all bacteria in the mouth are harmful. In fact, your mouth hosts a delicate ecosystem of both good and bad bacteria. Here's why mouthwash's indiscriminate approach to bacteria can be problematic:

1. Disrupting the Oral Microbiome: The oral microbiome refers to the balance of microorganisms in your mouth. Disrupting this balance by killing all bacteria, including beneficial strains, can lead to various oral health issues.

2. Dry Mouth: Many mouthwashes contain alcohol, which can contribute to dry mouth. A dry mouth is a breeding ground for bad bacteria and can worsen bad breath over time.

3. Temporary Fix: Mouth rinse offers a short-lived solution, masking bad breath rather than addressing its root causes.

The Superiority of Tongue Scraping

Tongue scraping is an ancient practice rooted in Ayurvedic medicine that has been gaining recognition for its many benefits. It offers a targeted approach to oral hygiene that focuses on removing the source of bad breath—the bacteria-laden coating on the tongue. Here's why tongue scraping surpasses mouth rinse for oral health:

1. Selective Bacteria Removal: Unlike mouth rinse, which wipes out all bacteria, tongue scraping removes the specific layer of harmful bacteria and debris that accumulates on the tongue's surface, preserving the beneficial ones.

2. Preservation of Oral Microbiome: Tongue scraping respects the delicate balance of good and bad bacteria in your mouth, promoting a healthier oral microbiome.

3. Long-Term Freshness: By addressing the root cause of bad breath, tongue scraping provides lasting freshness rather than just a temporary fix.

Scientific Support for Tongue Scraping

1. A study published in the International Journal of Ayurveda Research in 2010 found that tongue scraping was effective in reducing the total bacterial count on the tongue's surface while preserving the oral microbiome.

2. Research published in the Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research in 2017 reported that tongue scraping significantly reduced oral bacteria levels, supporting improved oral hygiene and reduced risk of dental problems.

Incorporating Tongue Scraping into Your Routine

Tongue scraping is a simple and cost-effective practice that you can easily incorporate into your daily oral care routine:

1. Purchase a tongue scraper made of stainless steel, copper, or plastic with a rounded edge.

2. After waking up in the morning, before eating or drinking, gently scrape your tongue from back to front, repeating this motion 5-10 times.

3. Rinse the scraper with warm water after each pass.

4. Finish by rinsing your mouth with warm water or a natural mouthwash if desired.

Conclusion

In the ongoing debate of tongue scraping vs. mouth rinse, tongue scraping emerges as the clear winner for preserving the delicate balance of your oral microbiome while effectively combatting bad breath. By opting for tongue scraping, you can enjoy lasting freshness and a healthier mouth without the unintended consequences of mouthwash. As research continues to uncover the importance of a balanced oral microbiome, tongue scraping is a simple yet powerful practice to embrace for optimal oral health.

Sources:

1. International Journal of Ayurveda Research - "Comparative evaluation of the antimicrobial efficacy of 0.2% Chlorhexidine, Ozonated water and Tongue scraper in reducing the Mutans streptococci count in children: An in vivo study"
2. Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research - "Comparison of the Effect of Tongue Scraper and Toothbrush on the Microbiological Profile of the Saliva and Tongue Coating"

 

Author: